Scientists found “echoes” in space that contradict Einstein’s theory of relativity

Stephen Hawking elaborated in 1974 theoretical arguments about black holes that contradict the theory of general relativity of Albert Einstein. These ideas suggest the existence of something called “Hawking radiation”, which is still controversial today, since Einstein’s proposals have proven to be correct on many occasions from space observations. But that may be about to change thanks to a new detection of gravitational waves.

When two neutron stars collided and created a powerful earthquake in the universe, their gravitational waves traveled through space until scientists were able to detect them on Earth in 2017. This apparently validated the general theory of relativity. But now, examining the recordings of these waves, a pair of physicists believe that they have found evidence that a black hole has appeared there that would actually violate Einstein’s model.

Einsten vs Hawking

Artistic representation of a black hole
Artistic representation of a black hole (Image: XMM-Newton, ESA, NASA)

In general relativity, black holes are infinitely compacted singularities, surrounded by horizons of smooth events through which no light, energy or matter can escape. Simple and confirmed with all the data that astronomers have managed to collect from black holes so far.

But Hawking said in his articles that the edges of black holes are not that smooth. He established the hypothesis of quantum mechanics that allows Hawking radiation to escape. In short, particles and antiparticles form in pairs for the briefest of moments, from the vacuum of space. They then quickly disintegrate with each other. When this occurs at the limit of the event horizon, there is a likelihood that one member of the pair will form inside, and the other outside, that is, one of the pair’s components could escape the black hole.

As a result, the black hole emits radiation, formed by particles that escape the event horizon, which causes the black hole to lose mass. In the years following this theory, several alternative models emerged where Einstein’s smooth and perfect event horizons would be replaced by more fragile and confusing membranes, in an attempt to validate Hawking’s idea.

More recently, some physicists have predicted that, in the case of newly formed black holes, this cloudiness would be intense enough to reflect gravitational waves, producing a kind of echo.

Echoes and uncertainties

Echoes and uncertainties

After detecting gravitational waves generated by the collision of neutron stars located in the elliptical galaxy NGC 4993, 130 million light years from Earth, two physicists argue that they found this echo. According to them, a black hole formed when the neutron stars merged, and now it is emitting this signal as if it were an echoing bell and, in a way, “running over” Einsteinian black hole physics.

There is still no certainty about this detection, but if the echo is real, it must be the result of the quantum “confusion” of a black hole, according to the study’s co-author, Niayesh Afshordi, a physicist at the University of Waterloo in Canada. He explains that “in Einstein’s theory of relativity, matter can orbit around black holes at great distances, but it must fall into the black hole near the event horizon.” Therefore, near the black hole, there should be no “loose” material to echo gravitational waves. Even black holes that are surrounded by material discs must have an empty zone around their event horizons, he said.

In contrast, the “time delay” that the two researchers observed in the echoes “can only be explained if some quantum structure is outside the event horizon” of the black hole. But it is important to note that the data from existing gravitational wave detectors is difficult to interpret properly and can result in false positives, which is why there are still doubts.

The study divides the opinion of other scientists. While some found the work compelling, others remain skeptical. Even though the echo is real, researchers still do not know exactly what type of astrophysical object produced the phenomenon; that is, there is still no concrete evidence that the result of the fusion of the stars was really a black hole, or some other short-lived object, such as a hypermassive neutron star.

Regardless of what this data means, it is certainly worth exploring further, and the scientific community agrees. If Hawking’s theory is proven, it could be the beginning of a new era for astrophysics.

Source: Live Science

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We use cookies for providing you with the best-possible user experience. By using PrivacySavvy, you accept our privacy policy.
Cookies settings
Privacy & Cookie policy
Privacy & Cookies policy
Cookie name Active

Privacy Policy

What information do we collect?

We collect information from you when you register on our site or place an order. When ordering or registering on our site, as appropriate, you may be asked to enter your: name, e-mail address or mailing address.

What do we use your information for?

Any of the information we collect from you may be used in one of the following ways: To personalize your experience (your information helps us to better respond to your individual needs) To improve our website (we continually strive to improve our website offerings based on the information and feedback we receive from you) To improve customer service (your information helps us to more effectively respond to your customer service requests and support needs) To process transactions Your information, whether public or private, will not be sold, exchanged, transferred, or given to any other company for any reason whatsoever, without your consent, other than for the express purpose of delivering the purchased product or service requested. To administer a contest, promotion, survey or other site feature To send periodic emails The email address you provide for order processing, will only be used to send you information and updates pertaining to your order.

How do we protect your information?

We implement a variety of security measures to maintain the safety of your personal information when you place an order or enter, submit, or access your personal information. We offer the use of a secure server. All supplied sensitive/credit information is transmitted via Secure Socket Layer (SSL) technology and then encrypted into our Payment gateway providers database only to be accessible by those authorized with special access rights to such systems, and are required to?keep the information confidential. After a transaction, your private information (credit cards, social security numbers, financials, etc.) will not be kept on file for more than 60 days.

Do we use cookies?

Yes (Cookies are small files that a site or its service provider transfers to your computers hard drive through your Web browser (if you allow) that enables the sites or service providers systems to recognize your browser and capture and remember certain information We use cookies to help us remember and process the items in your shopping cart, understand and save your preferences for future visits, keep track of advertisements and compile aggregate data about site traffic and site interaction so that we can offer better site experiences and tools in the future. We may contract with third-party service providers to assist us in better understanding our site visitors. These service providers are not permitted to use the information collected on our behalf except to help us conduct and improve our business. If you prefer, you can choose to have your computer warn you each time a cookie is being sent, or you can choose to turn off all cookies via your browser settings. Like most websites, if you turn your cookies off, some of our services may not function properly. However, you can still place orders by contacting customer service. Google Analytics We use Google Analytics on our sites for anonymous reporting of site usage and for advertising on the site. If you would like to opt-out of Google Analytics monitoring your behaviour on our sites please use this link (

Do we disclose any information to outside parties?

We do not sell, trade, or otherwise transfer to outside parties your personally identifiable information. This does not include trusted third parties who assist us in operating our website, conducting our business, or servicing you, so long as those parties agree to keep this information confidential. We may also release your information when we believe release is appropriate to comply with the law, enforce our site policies, or protect ours or others rights, property, or safety. However, non-personally identifiable visitor information may be provided to other parties for marketing, advertising, or other uses.


The minimum information we need to register you is your name, email address and a password. We will ask you more questions for different services, including sales promotions. Unless we say otherwise, you have to answer all the registration questions. We may also ask some other, voluntary questions during registration for certain services (for example, professional networks) so we can gain a clearer understanding of who you are. This also allows us to personalise services for you. To assist us in our marketing, in addition to the data that you provide to us if you register, we may also obtain data from trusted third parties to help us understand what you might be interested in. This ‘profiling’ information is produced from a variety of sources, including publicly available data (such as the electoral roll) or from sources such as surveys and polls where you have given your permission for your data to be shared. You can choose not to have such data shared with the Guardian from these sources by logging into your account and changing the settings in the privacy section. After you have registered, and with your permission, we may send you emails we think may interest you. Newsletters may be personalised based on what you have been reading on At any time you can decide not to receive these emails and will be able to ‘unsubscribe’. Logging in using social networking credentials If you log-in to our sites using a Facebook log-in, you are granting permission to Facebook to share your user details with us. This will include your name, email address, date of birth and location which will then be used to form a Guardian identity. You can also use your picture from Facebook as part of your profile. This will also allow us and Facebook to share your, networks, user ID and any other information you choose to share according to your Facebook account settings. If you remove the Guardian app from your Facebook settings, we will no longer have access to this information. If you log-in to our sites using a Google log-in, you grant permission to Google to share your user details with us. This will include your name, email address, date of birth, sex and location which we will then use to form a Guardian identity. You may use your picture from Google as part of your profile. This also allows us to share your networks, user ID and any other information you choose to share according to your Google account settings. If you remove the Guardian from your Google settings, we will no longer have access to this information. If you log-in to our sites using a twitter log-in, we receive your avatar (the small picture that appears next to your tweets) and twitter username.

Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act Compliance

We are in compliance with the requirements of COPPA (Childrens Online Privacy Protection Act), we do not collect any information from anyone under 13 years of age. Our website, products and services are all directed to people who are at least 13 years old or older.

Updating your personal information

We offer a ‘My details’ page (also known as Dashboard), where you can update your personal information at any time, and change your marketing preferences. You can get to this page from most pages on the site – simply click on the ‘My details’ link at the top of the screen when you are signed in.

Online Privacy Policy Only

This online privacy policy applies only to information collected through our website and not to information collected offline.

Your Consent

By using our site, you consent to our privacy policy.

Changes to our Privacy Policy

If we decide to change our privacy policy, we will post those changes on this page.
Save settings
Cookies settings